Sharing is caring!

Halloween night is a spooky and special time for kids. While some like to spend the night trick or treating and indulging in Halloween candy, others might prefer a scary movie or fun game.

​Would You Rather is a great game to play with kids of all ages. The whole family can ask these silly questions at the dinner table, on a road trip, or even in the classroom. These questions can be great conversation starters! Sometimes the answer or rationale can surprise you.

This is the perfect game to get everyone in the Halloween spirit. You can grab your free printable of choice: “Would You Rather Halloween Questions” or printable cards. The question cards can be printed and grabbed from at random, whereas the worksheet is something the whole family would answer together. Scroll to the bottom of this post for your free download – no email address required.

This list of Halloween questions are also great story prompts. Teachers, feel free to use these questions in the classroom or for personal use. Everyone is sure to have a great time and lots of laughs! 

Related: FREE DOWNLOAD: 4 Spook-tacular Halloween Coloring Pages

“Would You Rather” Questions For Kids Halloween Edition

1. Would you rather be able to cast spells like a witch or howl at the moon like a werewolf?
2. Would you rather be able to cast spells like a witch or see in the dark like a bat?
3. Would you rather be able to fly like a bat or breathe underwater like a mermaid?
4. Would you rather be able to fly like a bat or have the strength of a werewolf?
5. Would you rather be able to jump like a cat or run super fast like a werewolf?
6. Would you rather be able to fly like a ghost or run super fast like a zombie?
7. Would you rather be able to fly like a witch or turn invisible like a ghost?
8. Would you rather be able to see in the dark like a bat or have the strength of a werewolf?
9. Would you rather be able to talk to bats or talk to spiders?
10. Would you rather be able to talk to spiders or communicate with owls?
11. Would you rather be able to talk to spiders or control bats with your mind?
12. Would you rather be able to turn into a bat or a black cat at will?
13. Would you rather be able to turn into a bat or a black cat whenever you want?
14. Would you rather be able to turn into a bat or a werewolf at will?
15. Would you rather be able to turn into a bat or turn into a black cat?
16. Would you rather be able to turn into a ghost or a zombie at will?
17. Would you rather be able to turn into a ghost or a zombie whenever you want?
18. Would you rather be a friendly ghost or a mischievous witch?
19. Would you rather be a scarecrow or a mummy for a day?
20. Would you rather be chased by a friendly monster or a friendly vampire?
21. Would you rather be scared by a spooky movie or a haunted house?
22. Would you rather carve a pumpkin or decorate a Halloween cookie?
23. Would you rather dress up as a zombie or a superhero?
24. Would you rather go on a haunted hayride or explore a haunted maze?
25. Would you rather go to a haunted carnival or a haunted amusement park?
26. Would you rather go trick-or-treating in the rain or in the snow?
27. Would you rather go trick-or-treating with friends or have a Halloween party at home?
28. Would you rather go trick-or-treating with superheroes or with villains?
29. Would you rather go trick-or-treating with your favorite movie character or your favorite book character?
30. Would you rather have a black cat follow you everywhere or a ghostly shadow?
31. Would you rather have a black cat that brings you good luck or a black cat that brings you treats?
32. Would you rather have a black cat that brings you good luck or a black cat that can grant wishes?
33. Would you rather have a black cat that brings you good luck or a black cat that can talk?
34. Would you rather have a black cat that can talk or a black cat that can perform magic tricks?
35. Would you rather have a broomstick or a magic carpet as your mode of transportation?
36. Would you rather have a broomstick or a magic potion that grants temporary superpowers?
37. Would you rather have a broomstick or a magic staff as your magical tool?
38. Would you rather have a candy corn-shaped pillow or a bat-shaped blanket?
39. Would you rather have a cauldron full of candy or a magic wand?
40. Would you rather have a haunted amusement park or a haunted movie theater nearby?
41. Would you rather have a haunted amusement park or a haunted water park nearby?
42. Would you rather have a haunted amusement park or a haunted zoo nearby?
43. Would you rather have a haunted attic or a haunted basement?
44. Would you rather have a haunted bookshelf or a haunted toy chest?
45. Would you rather have a haunted bookshelf or a haunted wardrobe?
46. Would you rather have a haunted carnival in your backyard or a haunted maze in your living room?
47. Would you rather have a haunted carnival in your backyard or a haunted zoo in your neighborhood?
48. Would you rather have a haunted circus or a haunted zoo as a field trip?
49. Would you rather have a haunted closet or a haunted basement?
50. Would you rather have a haunted dollhouse or a haunted board game?
51. Would you rather have a haunted doll or a haunted painting in your room?
52. Would you rather have a haunted Ferris wheel or a haunted carousel?
53. Would you rather have a haunted house next door or a spooky graveyard in your backyard?
54. Would you rather have a haunted mirror in your room or a haunted clock that chimes at midnight?
55. Would you rather have a haunted mirror in your room or a haunted painting on your wall?
56. Would you rather have a haunted painting in your room or a haunted mirror?
57. Would you rather have a haunted roller coaster or a haunted carousel?
58. Would you rather have a haunted roller coaster or a haunted Ferris wheel?
59. Would you rather have a haunted roller coaster or a haunted haunted house ride?
60. Would you rather have a haunted tree in your backyard or a haunted well in your basement?
61. Would you rather have a jack-o’-lantern with a happy face or a scary face?
62. Would you rather have a magic broomstick or a magic cauldron?
63. Would you rather have a magic broomstick or a magic cauldron that can make any treat you want?
64. Would you rather have a magic broomstick or a magic cauldron that grants wishes?
65. Would you rather have a magic broomstick or a magic crystal ball?
66. Would you rather have a magic broomstick or a magic wand that grants wishes?
67. Would you rather have a magic broomstick that cleans your room or a magic cauldron that makes endless candy?
68. Would you rather have a magic cauldron that creates candy or a magic mirror that tells jokes?
69. Would you rather have a magic wand or a magic ring?
70. Would you rather have a magic wand that can make objects disappear or a magic potion that can make you fly?
71. Would you rather have a magic wand that grants wishes or a magic cauldron that creates costumes?
72. Would you rather have a pet black cat or a pet bat?
73. Would you rather have a pet owl or a pet spider?
74. Would you rather have a potion that turns you into a werewolf or a potion that turns you into a vampire?
75. Would you rather have a pumpkin-shaped house or a haunted mansion?
76. Would you rather have a spider web-covered room or a room full of floating ghosts?
77. Would you rather have vampire fangs or werewolf claws?
78. Would you rather visit a haunted castle during the day or a haunted forest at midnight?
79. Would you rather visit a haunted castle on a stormy night or a haunted forest during a full moon?
80. Would you rather visit a haunted castle or a haunted forest?
81. Would you rather visit a haunted forest at night or a haunted graveyard at midnight?
82. Would you rather visit a haunted forest in the fog or a haunted graveyard on a full moon night?
83. Would you rather visit a haunted forest with friendly creatures or a haunted graveyard with talking tombstones?
84. Would you rather visit a haunted forest with talking animals or a haunted graveyard with friendly spirits?
85. Would you rather visit a haunted graveyard or a haunted mansion?
86. Would you rather visit a haunted mansion during the day or a haunted graveyard at night?
87. Would you rather visit a haunted mansion in the city or a haunted cabin in the woods?
88. Would you rather visit a haunted mansion on a stormy night or a haunted graveyard on Halloween?
89. Would you rather visit a haunted pirate ship or a haunted spaceship?

Related: “Trick or Treat” Halloween Tracing Practice Worksheet – FREE DOWNLOAD

​Would You Rather: Halloween Food Themed

1. Would you rather eat a bowl of eyeball cereal or a plate of skeleton-shaped pancakes?
2. Would you rather eat a bowl of eyeball soup or a plate of worm spaghetti?
3. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of candy spiders?
4. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of chocolate-covered crickets?
5. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of chocolate-covered insects?
6. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of eyeballs?
7. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of gummy eyeballs?
8. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of gummy worms?
9. Would you rather eat a bowl of slime or a plate of spider webs?
10. Would you rather eat a brain-shaped jelly or a worm-filled chocolate?
11. Would you rather eat a candy apple covered in bugs or a gummy worm-covered cupcake?
12. Would you rather eat a candy apple covered in slime or a chocolate bar filled with gummy worms?
13. Would you rather eat a candy apple covered in slime or a chocolate bar with creepy crawlies inside?
14. Would you rather eat a caramel apple covered in spiders or a chocolate bar filled with worms?
15. Would you rather eat a caramel apple or a bag of candy corn?
16. Would you rather eat a pumpkin-shaped cookie or a ghost-shaped marshmallow?
17. Would you rather eat a pumpkin-shaped lollipop or a ghost-shaped cookie?
18. Would you rather eat a spider-shaped lollipop or a bat-shaped cookie?
19. Would you rather eat a spooky sandwich or a creepy cupcake?
20. Would you rather eat pumpkin seeds or a whole raw onion?
21. Would you rather lick a witch’s green skin or a slimy frog?
22. Would you rather eat a pumpkin pie or a caramel apple?
23. Would you rather eat a giant spider or an eyeball?
24. Would you rather eat Halloween cookies or Halloween candy?

Would You Rather: Halloween Costume Theme

1. Would you rather have a costume that’s all black or all green?
2. Would you rather have a costume that’s all feathers or all sequins?
3. Would you rather have a costume that’s all glittery or all furry?
4. Would you rather have a costume that’s all glow-in-the-dark or all metallic?
5. Would you rather have a costume that’s all neon colors or all pastel colors?
6. Would you rather have a costume that’s all neon colors or all pastel colors?
7. Would you rather have a costume that’s all polka dots or all stripes?
8. Would you rather have a costume that’s all polka dots or all stripes?
9. Would you rather have a costume that’s all purple or all orange?
10. Would you rather have a costume that’s all rainbow colors or all animal prints?
11. Would you rather have a costume that’s all rainbow colors or all metallic colors?
12. Would you rather have a costume that’s all red or all purple?
13. Would you rather have a costume that’s all silver or all gold?
14. Would you rather have a costume that’s all sparkly or all glow-in-the-dark?
15. Would you rather have a costume that’s all tie-dye or all camouflage?
16. Would you rather have a costume that’s all white or all blue?
17. Would you rather have a costume that’s all yellow or all pink?
18. Would you rather have a costume that’s covered in spiders or covered in bats?
19. Would you rather have a costume that’s too big or one that’s too small?
20. Would you rather have a pumpkin-shaped candy bucket or a skull-shaped candy bucket?
21. Would you rather have a costume that glows in the dark or one that changes colors?
22. Would you rather have a costume that glows in the dark or one that makes spooky sounds?
23. Would you rather wear a ghost costume or a monster costume?
24. Would you rather wear a skeleton mask or a zombie mask?
25. Would you rather wear a vampire cape or a superhero cape?
26. Would you rather wear a vampire cape or a superhero mask?
27. Would you rather wear a homemade costume or a store-bought costume?
28. Would you rather wear a witch hat or a pirate hat?
29. Would you rather wear a witch hat or a vampire cape?
30. Would you rather wear a witch hat or a wizard hat?
31. Would you rather wear a witch hat or a wizard robe?
32. Would you rather have a witch’s broom or a vampire’s cape?
33. Would you rather dress like Wonder Woman or Harry Potter?
34. Would you rather have a scary costume or a silly costume?
35. Would you rather be a headless horseman or Darth Vader?
36. Would you rather have the most creative costume or the most scary costume?

Related: 115+ Funny Would You Rather Questions For Kids

Would You Rather: Halloween Character Edition

1. Would you rather have a friendly ghost follow you everywhere or a friendly zombie?
2. Would you rather have a friendly ghost or a friendly vampire as a roommate?
3. Would you rather have a friendly ghost or a friendly zombie as a best friend?
4. Would you rather have a friendly vampire or a friendly werewolf as a neighbor?
5. Would you rather have a friendly witch or a friendly werewolf as your teacher?
6. Would you rather have a ghostly friend or a monster friend?
7. Would you rather have a ghostly friend who can make you invisible or a monster friend who can make you super strong?
8. Would you rather have a skeleton friend or a mummy friend?
9. Would you rather have a pumpkin-headed scarecrow or a pumpkin-headed ghost as a friend?
10. Would you rather have a skeleton friend who can dance or a ghost friend who can tell jokes?
11. Would you rather have a skeleton friend who can juggle or a ghost friend who can dance?
12. Would you rather have a skeleton friend who can play the guitar or a ghost friend who can sing?
13. Would you rather have a skeleton friend who can play the piano or a ghost friend who can sing?

Related: Halloween Activities – 45+ Fun Ideas For Toddlers & Kids

Would You Rather: Halloween Party Edition 

1. Would you rather have a Halloween party in a haunted house or a pumpkin patch?
2. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only ghosts or only vampires?
3. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only ghosts or only witches?
4. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only ghosts or only zombies?
5. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only mummies or only ghosts?
6. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only skeletons or only bats?
7. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only vampires or only ghosts?
8. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only vampires or only skeletons?
9. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only vampires or only witches?
10. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only witches or only ghosts?
11. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only witches or only skeletons?
12. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only witches or only werewolves?
13. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only witches or only zombies?
14. Would you rather have a Halloween party with only zombies or only skeletons?

Free Printable Halloween Would You Rather Games

Click the link. Your printable will open in a new tab on your browser for you to download.

Halloween Would You Rather Cards

Halloween Would You Rather Worksheet